vinutirr, AW1Nfl (A KO/VICIA5 ii/A,:..N.I.roW,L NS, ise&4. 14.„ roX,: 1111.,./ itiOgWoUitIZ%0.29:4'214.1 - W.1'W ■ 1 4„ . re TRO ETIZOITJEWISII 61RONICIA - frir 1 14, r or&A me" nrijo-, reiThL a right to enter if she meets with the rules and regula- tions prescribed. She is refused admission and at first no reason is Published Weekly by The Jewish Chronicle Publishing Co., Inc. RABBI LEON FRAM given, later vague ones are issued and now we learn Joseph J. Cummins, President and Editor that the reasons cannot be given because, as has been Jacob H. Schakne, General Manager stated, "Nor is it in the public interest to disclose the Steiger. which once existed between religion In order to carry out an education- gostodIce at Detroit, Almost the entire American Yiddish facts upon which each decision is based, since the in- and other arts and sciences may ham, Entered as fiecond11,1 3 ..m.a4:: ,111, :rAhd 3.,:t 1,4.ler:,hal . tli al experiment, I once asked several been accidental. In the case of meth press commented in editorials and friends what they thought was themost formation is often of a most confidential kind and other articles on the acquittal of Stan- striking evidence of human progress. cine, the relation seems to have bell General Offices and Publication Building would not be obtained at all if it were not treated as islaw Steiger, who was tried in Lem- One answered: the radio. • Another; organic. The separation of the tr. 525 Woodward Avenue confidential." This has much of the flavor of star berg, Poland, on the charge of having the aeroplane. A third: the telegraph. was unnatural. It is generally admit Cable Address: Chronicle bomb at President Wojcie- thrown a ted, by the medical fraternity, that Telephone: Cadillac 1040 A fourth: the automobile. A fifth: chamber proceedings and is violative of the Anglo- chowski. London Office: mental attitudes exercise a tremendou preventive medicine. 14 Stratford Place, London, W. I, England. Saxon theory that a person should be informed of the influence upon bodily health; that it • The Forward takes the acquittal as I wonder how ninny people would charges made against him even if the actual person who a sign that there is yet light in the think of naming a preventive medi- confidence and good cheer, and pow, • $3.00 Per Year Subscription, in Advance of resistance implied in religious faith world. The praiseworthy action of the cine as the most conspicuous manifest- makes the charges is not disclosed. are invaluable allies in the battle with To insure publication, all correspondence and news matter must reach this Ukrainian revolutionary organization office by Tuesday evening of each week. We still have the feeling that the State Department in Poland in proving that its member, ation of human progress. It impresses disease. Had the scientific physicians real- Olshansky, was the one who threw the me as the most intelligent reply. I The Detroit Jewlrh Chronicle in•ites correspondence on subjects of interest is persisting in a position taken thoughtlessly and now believe we may legitimately question ized earlier the inadequacy of a purely to the Jewish people, but disclaims rmponelbility for an Indorsement of the this action of that revolutionary the ultimate value of all the devices of refuses to change that position and hopes to excuse bomb, d by the writers. views ex mechanistic view of healing, and had body was the ray of light through the seed p which have been invented in our the ministers of religion held on to the itself by specious and irrelevent arguments. darkness of the Steiger trial. While age. It is doubtful whether we are traditions of faith-healing, had some Tebet 15, 5686 January 1, 1926 We trust that the present Congress will clear the this trial demonstrated the unparal- really happier than our fathers who form of co-operation been established meanness of the Polish anti-Se• knew nothing of them. As the means statute books of all vestiges of the war spirit as evi- leled between religion and medicine—civili- mites, the verdict was a heavy blow increase in velocity, l zation might have been spared these denced by such laws as enable the department to offer for anti-Semitism in Poland. of communication The Steiger Acquittal. the tempo of our lives is accelerated mushroom healing cults. As it is, ig- GG some sort of alibi, no matter how weak. "We do not believe," says the For- and we develop nervous afflictions, of nored alike by the clergy and by med- Stanislaw Steiger, the Jewish student, was acquitted ward, "that the acquittal was due to which our fathers knew nothing. You ical science, the secret of healing by a more liberal course of the Polish gov- would have a difficult time of it try- of the charge of throwing a bomb at the President of faith passed into the hands of adven- ernment, although we do believe that Mg to prove that a generation which Poland. The acquittal was expected for the only wit- turers and free lances—uneducated Yiddish Theaters. ry the Polish people can show as much is always in a hurry is better off than either in religion or in medicine—who ness against the defendant was a vaudeville dancer a generation which does things in its beauty, kindnes s and justice lei s every capitalized their craft and set it up in In no sphere of Jewish life in America is there own sweet ti n, other people. This ver ct, owever, whose reputation was not the best for veracity. The competition—highly successful com- due solely to the fact that the en- But everyone will agree that to elim- petition—against both medicine and confession of Olshansky, the Ukrainian revolutionist, stronger evidence of the will to survive than in the was accusation was too absurdly built theater. At the beginning of the century there were tire the church. should have been sufficient reason for dismissing the theater. uo ki;oy isPoolnislt naontis-oSneomitoicrygoverindment Thescience of medicine, I believe, is Is it true, you will ask, that these the only field of human activity to healing cults can cure diseases with- case, but certain sinister dark forces connected with two Yiddish theaters, at the close of the first quarter otherwise in such a "gainft out the aid of specific medicines, sur- there are 30 theaters distributed from New York to lyreasps,plim thoey hteergmonopioroog the Lemberg police opposed such action. "Although not no dangerous for the ahead"m gery, antiseptics or antitoxins? Of Los Angeles. The number is not the only significant disease hot t all nt htoe tinfamous g There has been a persistent effort to make a Drey- ,sicznutisuxteod sweep e ou or .s. course, it is not true. Every physi- feature, but there is a difference in purpose, outlook ' l I lee7Ii i a s htri7 l i e t Wa tis w trial hwal. i the fathers of r dsi cian, funeral director, and clergyman fus or Beiles case out of the Steiger trial. We could ma- t - ealy ndpeofixoitm of hhe oeidarhtah v. e S btmeafi and compass which is even more important than mere in the purpose of those responsible for tah reiof,acoe ndtytp knows that in dealing with the major never view the case in that light but this sedulous repe- t, follow- up i:1 both or cases, ) organic diseases these cults kill often. numerical increase. The Yiddish theater of a quarter the ws frame-up ni th r- er than they heal. How then have of t tition of "frame up" aroused the whole world and par- vl oasntqluoigsshed.soo;l'iuo b t efroctuolrosoi n s d is i p ohe Je ,_ thing to meet the en the trial wil thirIC een inte re' st, heaved e century ago was conceived as som they been able to maintain their pres- ticularly the Jewish world to the importance of the amusement needs of those who were unable to speak a sigh of relief at the news that Steig- Ia are under control. Diabetes, the tige? Here enters the second expla- venereal diseases, and cancer, will case. w n i tm ass f r e e . " , e p r o iS nation of the paradox of medicines be- the English language and was on a vulgar and cheap soon be in hand. The discovery of the e Jewish Daily News ing given a coal reception in the hour , The Dreyfus case was a fabrication out of whole plane without any pretense at artistic or literary corn- bacterial origin of disease, the develop- differences between of its greatest triumph. il o aurtly thatt hthe cloth, backed and furthered by the military clique of petence, or as a competitor with the English-spoken the Steiger ment of antitoxin and asepsis to-fight trial and the Beilis trial, While it is true that thanks to the d the inyentaiol i o n ei e po ic te tr o ia,to7 e France; the Belles case was the hoary "blood libel" drama. The Yiddish stage has left much of this defi- on the one hand, and the Dreyfus trial, the f hoosottile t hobtaco ministrations of preventive medicine, e o s f th h nature w a the number of people who are sick is i I t ee itg ter Vhs h ,,e o to io t hnero. r e, o t monstrosity manufactured by the government to arouse o the the aa peril out of major ope rati ns— growing constantly less, the number niter y behind. The casts today are made up of men anti-Semitic feeling. The Steiger case was based upon so dangerous as were the accusations these have actually increased the span of people who think they are sick is s and women of arti tic integrity and ability. nliafie. of in hunzdic growing greater every day. This is or dliecitliscoannU the g Dreyfus r inl nth o thvel a fact. A bomb was thrown at the President of then The plays are for the most part excellent realistic science evidently we be- not the fault of the physicians. It is cases, Polish Republic; a perjured witness came forth who would be a new weapon in the hands of hold, certainly the best and perhaps due to the speed of the twentieth cen- identified Steiger, but it cannot be seriously maintained vehicles, although frequently the melodramatic, vul- the anti-Semitic agitators in Poland. the only real, exemplifications of the tury life, of which I spoke in the be- term human progress. How does it that the Polish government, either civil or military, at- gar and inartistic bulk large in the repertory. This ginning. Men exhaust their nervous "Our joy at Steiger's acquittal is, pandering is understandable when we realize that the therefore, happen, then, that the age which is so energies in the unremitting hunt for threefold: first, because an tempted to use the case as a basis for anti-Semitic dis- conspicuous for these palpable tri- profits, and leave their minds as wil- audiences are still uneducated in the finer appreciation innocent man was freed; secondly, that crimination. in Poland a new framed up ac- umphs of medicine is conspicuous al- dernesses haunted by fears. Women of dramatic values. We know that many of the ar- even cusation against Jewry has been mis- no for the ever enlarging circles of men have little to do and either waste them- We are not offering apologies for the Grabski gov- tists connected with the better casts make the conces- selves in meaningless pastimes, or con- and thirdly, that all foes of among whom the medical practitioner ernment. Its record for stupid discrimination, economic sions to the demand for inferior plays with ill-concealed carried; is held in utter distrust? Never in all centrate their attention upon them- Israel in Poland have thus suffered a its history has the practice of medi- selves. That's a sure way of getting blundering and political log rolling is such that any great disappointment." displeasure. cine encountered such open hostility as ' an imaginary illneta—to thing about excuses one may offer would sound hollow and uncon- "A different verdict in the Steiger The Yiddish stage has become dignified and fully trial could not even be imagined," says it encounters in this day. Open any yourself. vincing. But despite all its blundering we do not be- Saturday newspaper and you will find It is upon these victims of worry, the Jewish World of Philadelphia. lieve that the Grabski government hoped to make cap- conscious of its own excellence and does not have to "What is to be wondered at is the per- notices of dozens of churches and other these intellectual starvelings and nor- hide in obscure corners lest some critic laugh it out of more or less religious societies whose vous wrecks, that the healing cults sistence of the prosecution and of the ital out of the Steiger trial. The whole affair was too only reason for existence is to oppose thrive. Their success in the treatment department of justice in Poland transparent and, what is more, the Grabski regime did existence. The Yiddish Art Theater Company toured entire the ministrations of medical science. of the imaginary ailments of the twen- Europe with exceptional artistic success. Some of the in continuing the trial and torturing These churches regard the doctor as tieth century is so complete, that their not need it to carry out its economic program. innocent victim, even after the 01- the very incarnation of mortal error, failure with real diseases becomes by critics of England paid it high praise. The Vilna Troupe its confession and the official an- During the entire period of the trial and long be- was on more than one occasion compared with the Mos- shansky nouncement of it by the German Min- as the embodiment of the devil himself. comparison insignificant. Their following must now be counted The physician has not been able to fore a serious effort at rapprochement by means of the cow Art Theater. It is unfortunate that as yet Amer- inter of the Interior in the German in the millions. help these victims of modern life be- Reichstag. That the entire affair was Polish-Jewish agreement was attempted. The childish permanent home for this How shall we account for this cause he has not learned either to deal ica is not able to provide a nothing but an anti-Semitic cobweb expedient of a frame up of a single individual could not with the human soul or to co-operate strange paradox of medicine being the could be seen even immediately after enterprise. with the minister of religion. The min- most distrusted at a time when it is help the Polish government out of its economic and po- Steiger's liberation, when the hooli- In our own city the Yiddish players are capable, ar- gan organizations of Lemberg were in- doing the most good? Two explana- ister of religion has not been able to litical bogs. The statesmen of Poland are sufficiently help them because these busy worldly tions offer themselves. The first has citing to anti-Jewish excesses in that realistic to know that the profound maladjustments of tistic and genuinely serious about their work. men and women had never found time to do with the history of medicine it- It is enough that the Jews have to go to the house of worship. And But what is important is the fact that the Yiddish city. self. The second is founded upon some Polish life cannot be corrected by such infantile meth- to live in such an atmosphere." what does the faith-healing cult do for of the peculiar conditions of life in the theater is animated by the spirit and belief that it has "Justice has triumphed," says the ods. them? It is a very simple process. It twentieth century. Jewish Daily' Eagle. "The voice of a definite place in the cultural life of America. It of- takes their little self-centered minds First, medicine, like all the other We are pleased to learn of the acquittal and hope justice has spoken, and Poland has just as they are and merely changes arts and sciences, was from the neo- fers its contribution as a competitor for the interest of been spared an infamous blood-stain. that it will prove a salutary lesson to over-zealous police the images within them, as one lithic age until the sixteenth century all, Poland is a European coun- officials who would prove their patriotism by suppres- the theater goers. It holds that the Yiddish drama by After changes slides in a stereopticon ma- closely associated with religion. The try. How was such an intrigue pos- reason of its realism and artistic quality has a right to chine. Instead of the slide: "The world medicine man of the primitive neolith- sible? It was possible because in Po- sion and frame up. is all evil and, I am ill," it introduces ic tribe, as among the American In- survive. land they came to regard Jew-baiting the slide: "The world is all love, there dians, is a combination of priest and as a sort of patriotic duty. But the How far can this integration go? No doubt the con- is no evil, and I am well." This works healer. Just as painting and sculpture has emerged to the surface and sciousness of absence of Immigration has given a decid- truth given of course, sufficient concentra- began with making images of the gods, Secretary Kellogg's Answer. h il l triumphed v. f . i tt h hoth;olas s o j oufsttico has tion and sufficient naivete. It gives architecture with building temples for ed impetus to those who value Yiddish and believe in its h be singing hymns peace to the jagged nerves and poise them, and music with At a recent dinner of the Council of Foreign Rela- perpetuation. With the best intentions, however„ it will people." to them, so medicine began as a cast- to the jaded body. "The panic which the Steiger ac- tions held in the Ritz Carlton Hotel, New York, Secre- not be possible to preserve it unle s a response is evoked quittal s If the healers would only limit their ing out of evil spirits from the body of has caused in anti-Semitic cir- tary of State Frank B. Kellogg gave his answer to the among the masses. Will the Yiddish stage attract those des of Poland shows the extent of man and a breathing in of the spirit practice to such cases of imaginary ill- ness or even to purely nervous disor- of the god. In the entire Bible there paper says in an- 1 many criticisms against his department due to the ex- whose mother speech is not Yiddish but who have their despair," l. the is to be found not a single word which ders, we might say More power to other editoria "ut the Polish anti- clusion of Countess Karolyi and Shapurji Saklatvala. learned it as they learn any other foreign language? them" and let them go on in the name can be translated as "doctor." All Sem ites do not understand that after God. But they cannot afford to Though these individuals were not specifically named Certain it is that a determined, brave effort is being all Poland has gained from the acquit- healing is done either by priest or by of discriminate. They have no know- The sole method was prayer yet they were the persons he had in mind from the tenor made to win large numbers as spectators. The actors tal much more than the Jewish peo- prophet. ledge or skill or technique. All their or laying on of the hands. Moses was go too far with lies. ca o You nnot of his remarks. He said: are competent. The plays have merit and strength. pie. truth is bound to come eventually. this type of a healer, so was Aaron, power over their patients lies in the vast impressive claims which they the High Priest, and so were the The Yiddish Theater in America should have the sup- The Polish anti-Semites have suffered prophets, Elijah and Elisha• The policy of this country as plainly indicated by the make, in their total denial in every berg. The Steig- a great defea port not only of those whose daily speech is Yiddish ease. For this reason, because I know of Congress is to keep certain specified classes of At this season of the year our Chris- ho pe. They gre ads er affair was th in ei r Lematest aliens out of the country. The State Department received tian neighbors are celebrating the that faith-healing is dependent upon hoped to have in the conviction of but who appreciate worth while work. Ir. ONLY N.A. 14WMAIMS e- DIGEST .1•1040.111 from the various diplomatic and consular agents of the United States all the information possible in relation to these undesirable aliens. He reviewed the legislation relating to exclusion of aliens which must be excluded, with particular refer- ence to those who advocate the overthrow of the goy- -) ernment of the United States by force and violence. Are we to believe that the Countess Karolyi and Saklatvala and others intended to advocate the over- throw of the government by force and violence? Even the most nervous would not believe that the countess had any such intentions and we doubt whether the con- fidential agents whose reports are kept secret were able to connect her with any such ideas. Unfortunately for the State Department the general law does not cover the particular case, consequently we are compelled to seek the reason for her exclusion in the undisclosed re- ports of the confidential agents. The answer is unsatisfactory for it fails to meet the test laid down by the department inasmuch as there is no evidence that the countess in particular comes with- in the class of undesirable aliens. There is a note in the defense which has the ap- pearance of a red herring. In his defense of exclusion the secretary said : "One would think from some of the comments in the press that a foreigner has some inher- ent right to come to the United States which is being denied by the State Department. No foreigner has such right whatever. Congress may admit or exclude any one it sees fit. The law has specified what classes shall be excluded and until the law is changed it will be enforced; and it will be enforced without regard to their station in life, for the law applies to prince and peasant alike." None of the critics of the State Department have assumed that an alien has rights which rise higher than the law passed by Congress. Nobody questions the sovereignity of the government nor its right to prescribe rules for entry into the country. But yet an alien does have a right to enter the United States if he comes with- in the provisions of the laws passed by Congress. Countess Karolyi had a right to apply for admission to the United States just as has any other European. If she wanted to come here as a quota immigrant she should be admitted if she satisfied .the requirements of the quota law. If she intended to visit us for pleasure, business, education or in the service of science she has ..szewnizga<*eszts.sgeizfcattzf THEY THAT KNOW MY SORROW They that know my sorrow add a spark to the fire of my heart When they ask me: How is thy beloved more precious than another love? Praises and dark sayings fail to tell of Him; He is all desirable; His majesty cannot be sought out ; Therefore do I clothe myself with terrors at His flight. Ah, pity me, and speak unto the heart so moved, Or comfort me; for how endure love and separa- tion? And His name is within me—live fire in my veins, Bound within my heart, shut up in my bones: And they rebuke me—they that despise my statutes— And they reproach me when I seek to serve Him, And they revile me when I give glory to His Name. They think to set me far, 0 God, from Thy service: But my suffering and oppression are better than Thine estrangement ; My portion and my pleasure, the sweet fruit of Thy law. Let my right hand forget—if I stand not before Thee; Let my tongue cleave—if I desire aught but Thy law. Lo, in mine ears the sound of Thy praise— The Red Sea and Sinai are witnesses to Thy great- ness: How shall my thoughts dwell on any but Thee? My heart and mine eyes will not suffer my feet to slip, For this, the Lord, is One, there is none beside Him. JEHUDAH HALEVI Jewlsa PuldIntioa Society . . larlf - rte "Jewish Science and Health" ! ,, i , the making of vast and unconditioned birth of Jesus. If you read the life of Steiger a new justification for their claims, I can foresee no success for the Jesus in the gospels you will find that, agitation and persecution of the Jews. like the career of the prophet Elijah, movement known as Jewish Science. Hence their despair. Some consola- I am not uttering a wish, I am mere- it was largely occupied with healing. tion, however, they may find in the ly expressing a humble judgment. It was through his healing—miracles- fact that their victim is a physical that he first gained recognition as a Jewish Science is, as the name betrays. wreck and suffering with tuberculo- man of God. So prominent in the gos- an imitation of Christian Science. Ob- sis, as a result of the inhuman suffer- serving that a large number of Jews pels are the medical labors of Jesus, ing and tortures he endured for the in New York City have turned to that they overshadow every other as- past 16 months. pect of his career; and Mary Baker Christian Science, Rabbis Morris Lich- "When a situation such as this tenstein and Clifton Ilarby Levy, both Eddy was able to find abundant Bibli- arises out of a trial," says the paper graduates of the Hebrew Union Col- cal support for her contention that Je- in its English section, "the original lege, decided to try to keep such Jews sus was a healer of the sick, and noth- significance of the proceedings be- ing more. within the fold of Judaism by offering comes obscured. The innocence or In those sections of Russia which them the same goods they get in Chris- guilt of a single accused becomes a have not yet escaped the darkness of tian Science but with a Jewish trade minor issue; the future of a whole the Middle Ages, there is a Jewish mark. This is a very worthy motive community is in peril." , group called the Chasidim, whose rab- indeed. The Jewish community can The writer thinks that "as long as bis are primarily faith healers. The afford to lose not the least of its mem- racial prejudice will continue to sway bers. Half the Jews of the world are healing shrines of the Catholic Church the conduct of nations, the Jewish are to be found in all parts of the still suffering hunger, still menaced by people will i.e forced to make sacrifices world. Some are centuries old. A new oppression. There is no one to help for the crimes and offenses, real or them but their fellow-Jews, especially one is about to be established in De- imaginary, of its members." Neither of America. With every Jew that troit. will "the doctrine involved in being Now it happened that in the course leaves the fold the hope of securing better than our neighbors" do. lie of those intellectual upheavals of the safety and freedom for the Jewish sees the only logical solution of the sixteenth century and thereabouts, people dwindles. problem, on the one hand, in "build- Many of these Christian Science which we know as the Renaissance and up our distinct political unity in Pal- the Reformation, that all the daugh- Jews are exceedingly wealthy. They estine" and on the other in powerful ters of religion—painting, sculpture, give freely of their money to build Jewish communities in countries like music, drama, philosophy—left the churches. That money might have the United States and England being material home and set up housekeep- gone to solve the problem of Jewish democratically and permanently or- ing for themselves. education and to settle Jewish farm- ganized to demand justice to Jews in Art began to deal with other than ers in Russia and in Palestine. If every civilized country. religious sahiects, and music began Rabbi Lichtenstein's book "Jewish "The existence of the American and to sing wonderfully of other than re- Science and Health" could hold these Canadian Jewish Congress made pos- ligious themes. And while some of straying sheep within Jewry. it would sible the perpetuation of Jewish mi- the finest creations of art, literature, perform a signal service. Many . eas nority rights at Versailles. The in- and music are still religious—these are using the cloak of Christian tercession of Anglo and Franco-Jew- have nevertheless established them- Science as a means of escaping Judo- ish public bodies only recently brought selves as separate and distinct ism, its burdens and its demands, and Hungary before the league to account branches of human activity. as an easy gateway into Gentile so- for the constitutionality of her "num- At about the same time medicine, ciety. It is true they are not succeed - erus clausus" legislation and evoked i too, too, declared itself independent of re- ing. The church manages to keep its her promise that steps will soon be !igloos faith. Physicians began to Jews together. Some Christian Science taken to amend it. An efficiency or- treat the human body purely as a ma- Churches in New York show such con- ganized Jewry, prepared to force the chine and began to regard themselves centration of Jews, that they have league to act when necessary, should virtually as engineers. They identi- been nicknamed "Christian Science make the possibility of a Steiger or fled themselves as a group with the Shuls." If Rabbi Levy's spiritual les- Dreyfus trial an absolute anomaly." materialistic philosophy. They be- sons could give these cowards a little The Jewish World of Cleveland re- came, if not anti-religious, largely ir- backbone, they would be performing counts all the famous anti-Jewish religious. They scorned the notion a signal service. Moreover, much of trials and blood accusations from 1900 patient's soul or his religious that a the literary material used by the faith- to 1925 and arrives at the conclusion faith had anything to do with his pros- healers is actually Jewish, taken from that nowhere has a false accusation poets for getting well. The presence the Jewish Bible, and it seemes a pity been fraught with danger for the en- of the minister in the sick-room was that Jews must adopt Christianity in tire Jewish community as in the last tolerated rather than welcomed. The order to learn the value of Jewish lit- Steiger trial in Poland. and nowhere body is a machine, they said. Give it has the accusation and the trial no alw erature. the proper fuel, grease it with oil, and A Jewish young woman of Chicago surd and so malicious as it was in this adjust its parts with steel tools, and came to me once and said, "I used to ease. it will go. be so miserably nervous, but I have This purely mechanistic interprets- Who steals another's good name joined Christian Science and now I am tom of medicine has now been proven makes himself poor indeed and not (Turn to next page.) to be an error. The close attachment enriches himself. SYNAiesenSWARI ',WO. 5W