(11RON131143
PAGE TEN
■■■■■■ 0 Present Director of
'os‘.111 s IL‘Ni lleW10112 ■ 1 1M11•IINMMIII.'% ■■■■■■■■■
Religious Education
Your Most Valuable Assets—
LIFE INSURANCE
,
1,
P a
"Is the Prevailing Relation Between
the Conservative and the Reform Jews
of Detroit a Wholesome One?"
By RABBI A. M. HERSHMAN
ACCIDENT and HEALTH INSURANCE
ckch
effects
(Editor's Note:—The following lecture was delivered by Rabbi
A. M. Hershman at the late Friday evening services at the Shaarey
Zedek Synagogue on Friday evening, Dec. 6. The Detroit Jewish
Zedek Synagogue on Friday evening, Dec. 6. Opinions from the
readers of The Detroit Jewish Chronicle are invited.)
INSURE YOUR LIFE
INSURE YOUR INCOME
Company.
And a Time to Speak.—Ecclesiastes
I propose to speak tonight on a Reform Jew. The Reform Jew has
a right to his ideas. The same right
subject which has engaged my atten- must be conceded to the Conservative
THE OLD LINE LIFE INSURANCE
distinguish the
IA
tion and agitated my mind for some Jew. He should not be interfered
work of our skil-
COMPANY OF AMERICA
time. Let me say at the very outset with in his efforts to make his chil-
led artisans.
0 S. A S. JACOBS
that I do so with no feigned hesita- dren safe for Conservative Judaism.
Thome, considering Life Insurance as
The principle which should guide the
A
tion
and
reluctance.
One
is
loath
to
re
invited
to
apply
to
Reform and the Conservative Jews
profession ■
raise an issue calculated to sow divi- in
their relation to one another is
sion in the community. I.know that this:
Let them both work together on
it would be politic for me to refrain all matters
and interests which they
from doing it. I should be unworthy have in common;
let them work sep-
GENERAL AGENTS
0
of my sacred office were I to permit arately when it comes to things with
We refinish or restore to look like new.
myself to be swayed by expediency or respect to which they disagree. Let
921 - 922 DIME BANK BUILDING
Our selection of beautiful upholstering material, .
policy. It is well to have peace in the the Reform Jew walk in the light he
Cadillac 4025.8589
RABBI LEON FRAM
community; but peace purchased at has. Let the Conservative Jew walk
ABE GUROVITCH
LEON GINSBURG
Unlimited.
the prohibitive price of principle by the light which is his. Let each
OA Associates:
BEN
KAPLOWITZ
MAX HAMBURGER
is undesirable. A situation exists work out his own salvation without
We are Agents for
which, unless the intrepid, earnest- let or hindrance from the other.
............................... YESHIBAH PLANS LAYING
Pia
Winthrop Furniture, famous for its re-
minded
men
and
women
in
our
midst
OF CORNERSTONE NOV. 22
This is the position which I have
resolve to face it and attack it with
markable reproduction of period An-
the view of changing it, will make consistently maintained for years. In
tiques. Though not exorbitantly priced,
NEW YORK—Sunday, Nov. 22, is eventually for the abdication of Con- an address given by me at Temple
it gives to all save experts the impres-
the date decided upon for the corner- servative and Orthodox Judaism in Beth El on the occasion of the dedi-
sion of age and pricelessness. An ex-
stone laying of the aeries of seven Detroit. We cannot afford to take a cation of its present premises, I said:
placid
and
complacent
view
of
the
•
"The
Reform
and
the
Conservative
ample — the fine Winthrop Desk, ;100.
buildings of the Yeshibah of Amer-
ica, the great institution of higher situation. Silence, at this time, may Jew should not quarrel one with the
Jewish learning which Orthodox Jew- be good policy, but it is poor princi- other. I should like to see every Jew
"There is a time to speak," says who has leanings towards Reform
ry of America Is erecting, Harris L. plc.
THE UNDOW COMPANY
author of Ecclesiastes. I want join and come under the influence of
Selig, executive director of the Ye- the
to
speak
tonight without any equivo- the temple. I should like to see every
liAltol‘fererd
ahibah College Builathe Fund, has
INCORPORATED
Jew who has leanings towards Con-
cation or mental reservation.
just announced.
Cadillac 2849
There is a groping for unity in our servative Judaism join and come un-
Because of the great significance of midst.
1935
Maraniette
Strenuous efforts are being der the influence of the Conservative
the day in the history of American
istingacti
a
o gf uet." e And, gkanndow
and World Jewry, leaders of the Ye- made to secure united action on the sY na
propagandist activities
of all the elements and sections thing
shibah campaign are planning impres- of the
community. This is as it carried on in the community, I added:
— Manufacturers of —
sive exercises for the corner-stone lay- should be. Deep down in the solid "Of course all Jews are one, but the
ing. Practically every college and un-
esreusbwhollushsbalaInbdeatnhde
iversity in America will have repre- foundations of Judaism lies imbedded fluestioTnheorfetesntahri
sentatives present to welcome the as one of the cornerstones the belief o,le
wife are said to be one; but it is one
world's first Jewish college to the acs- in the solidarity, the oneness o of the most frequent sources of mat-
dcmic life of America. Every Jewish Israel. In the eyes of Judaism, all rimonial infelicities that after mar-
organization in every city has been Jews constitute one people. In the riage either the husband or the wife
invited to send accredited delegates to eyes of the non-Jewish world, all claims to be that one." I then quoted
the affair. Jews form one people. Moreover,
some of the problems with which we the limerick:
confronted are of such propord There was once a lady of the Niger,
Join Finn of F. A. Gordon. are
tions and of so staggering a character Who went for a ride with a tiger.
that nothing but concerted effort
They returned from the ride
The many friends and clients of might enable us to cope with them.
With the lady inside—
David Cohen and Manning Cornfield Therefore, any attempt to achieve And a smile on the face of the tiger.
will be pleased to learn of their asso- unity in Jewry is laudable. Every
ciation as managers of Frank A. Gor- step taken to translate our much
It is clear to me that the temple
— Dealers in ---
don's new office, recently opened at vaunted and much wanted Jewish has been playing the role of the tiger
4739 Woodward avenue for the trans- solidarity into practical measures is in the limerick quoted. And when I
action of a general real estate and in- a step in the right direction. Never- say the temple, I do not mean to in-
surance business. Mr. Cohen is a theless, we dare not lose sight of the dulge in sweeping generalizations.
comparative newcomer to Detroit. fact that Jews differ among them- There are many members of the tem-
Ile is a member of the Toronto Bar selves. And let it not be said that ple who are perfectly free from all
and a graduate of the Osgoode Hall the differences which divide element missionary tendencies, who would
ALL YEAR ROUND
University. Mr. Cornfield, before en- from element are of no importance. scrupulously and conscientiously ab-
tering the real estate and insurance They are important; some of them stain from all propaganda. I, for
GROUND FLOOR
e,
field, was for five years employment are of vital importance. We dare not on place implicit faith and confi-
manager of the Fisher Body Works magnify them, neither dare we make dence in those men. When I say the
and has since had many years of ex- light of them. There is a cleavage temple, I mean the powers that be,
perience in the handling of all aorta on religious lines. There are the Re- those responsible for the shaping of
of real estate and insurance problems. formers, there are the Conservatives; the policy thereof. They seem to be
CORNER KALES
Frank A. Gordon came to-Detroit' and when I speak of Conservatives I obsessed with the notion that Con-
sonic years ago, after successfully include the Orthodox Jews. Mt Re- servative Judaism is a mere an-
subdividing thousands of acres in Buf- form Jew has his point of view. The lachronism, an anomaly, a phase of
falo. Transferring his operations to Conservative Jew has his. He cher- Judaism that has already spent its
Phone Lafayette 1711
DETROIT
Detroit only a few years ago, his ishes some convictions not shared by force; that Reform is the only form
unique methods have quickly and the Reform Jew. He holds some of Judaism to which all Jews should
firmly established him as Michigan's views which run counter to, are in- adhere. They speak of co-operation;
largest wholesale subdivider.
compatible with, those held by the they mean domination, monopoly. They
nod assent to the proposition that all
Jews are one; they would add, how-
ever, one in Reform Judaism. "Tem-
ple first," seems to be their motto.
Some of them would stop at no
maneuver to wean away our people
from the synagogue and win them
over to the temple.
All Jews are one in Reform Juda-
ism. Such, I contend, is the thesis of
ey:O:OnI.0:11..O:ONO:•:•:81:01.1180111.111.11 Ono
the temple. I shall not be hard put
.I.011
4II:011
to it to prove my contention. Here
■
114%
you have some of the evidence.
O
SU
About two years ago some men con-
lia
■
nected with the temple conceived the
R I
■
Ride Along to Peace and Prosperity
idea of a joint meeting of the Men's
Ile
Club of the temple and the Men's Club
0
•■
in a
of this congregation. It was arranged
—and I was no party to the arrange-
IV
ment—that the incumbent of this pul-
ell
pit should speak for the Men's Club of
O .
.
I
this congregation and the president
■ I
■
of the Central Conference of Ameri-
N
.
can Rabbis should speak for the Men's
..
Club of the temple. I had my misgiv-
I .
ings regarding the advisability of ac-
■
a
cepting the invitation. I could not
A Call on the Phone and you immediately
s l
understand why it was necessary to
O
have a Cab at your door.
1110
have the president of the conference
grace the meeting with his presence.
I I
I
I was assured, however, that the sole
s
purpose of the meeting was to pro-
mote good fellowship and make for a
better understanding between the
i ..
..;.;
Conservative and the Reform Jews.
■
At the urgent request of some of our
..
members, I accepted the invitation.
.
I asked what I should discuss at the
. .
meeting. It was suggested to me that
...
speak on the subject likely to bring
. . . .
both elements closer together.
. ■ e •
My misgivings, however, were more
than justified. I spoke on federation.
I ■
The president of the Central Confer-
I I s .
ence spoke on Reform Judaism. He
II ■
prefaced his address with the remark
O
that he found hmiself in an embar-
I N
rassing position. lie had been ad-
U.
vised that I would present the Ortho.
. .
dux view of Judaism and that he was
I
expected to state the position of Re-
I I
.
form. Nevertheless, he went on with
■
COMFORTABLE — COURTEOUS — CAREFUL
.1
the address prepared by him, glorify-
I R
ing Reform and presenting Orthodoxy
II
in a rather unfavorable light. When
GENERAL MOTORS BUILDING
I g
he was done, I whispered to my neigh-
■.■
bor on my left, an important digni-
tary in the temple: "Now pass around
Me
your membership application blanks;
:11:11:11:11:116.8..I.O:I:UXO:11:11:11:11:11:15:1:11:21:0:11:..6 I
this is what you have brought us here
for."
ERE is nothing 'a man appreciates more
Now, I ask, was it fair play? Was
there any justification for taking un-
han a mellow, cool, satisfying cigar. That's
due advantage of us? A host owes
his guest certain duties. Ile should
why every day more than a million La Palinas
not say aught designed to wound the
are smoked—why they are America's largest selling
feelings and sentiments of his guest;
he should not, under the cloak of hos-
cigar. Therefore, instead of giving unknown
pitality, seek to impose his views and
beliefs on him. The temple was our
"Christmas Specials", give him a box of La Palinas.
host. We were its guest. Can you
•,"FOR GENUINNE SAVINGS"
find a scintilla of justification for the
There's a wide assortment of sizes and shapes, at
treatment accorded to us? Of course,
some will say it was an unfortunate
prices that meet every purse. Ask your retailer.
misunderstanding. But was it • mis-
EVERYTHING FOR YOUR TABLE
understanding? So far as some or
CONGRESS CIGAR COMPANY, Philadelphia, Pa.
most of the members of the Men's
Club are concerned, it was. As far
as others are concerned, it was no
EMPIRE 70
misunderstanding; it was misrepre-
8044 TWELFTH STREET
sentation, pure and simple, a deliber-
ate plan to make converts to Reform
Judaism. I refused, at that meeting,
to he drawn into any controversy. My
main reason was that I had hoped
that out of this unfortunate affair
much good would come to the com-
Fer Automobiles, Trucks and Motor Boats.
munity. I reasoned thus: Now the
powers that be realize the absurd
length to which their proselytizing
zeal has led them, a wholesome reac-
Pieta Clo ■ ilala 4
tion will now set in. But I was mis-
■ 140 ■ S.W. Ammo.
taken. That episode seemed to have
With an "Old Line" Legal R
0
gents Wanted -- •
0 jACOBS INSURANCE AGENCY
0
0
0
•
Detroit Rendering Co.
TALLOW AND
POULTRY FOOD
Toys
HIDES, SKINS
AND PELTS
Detroit's Exclusive Toy Store
P. J. WEINSTO.
2500 ISABELLA STREET
13 1
CADILLAC
SQUARE
•
Checker Cab
EMPIRE 7000
Largest Company in Detroit
and the Finest Fleet of
Cabs In the Country
.
11
ec k er Cab Co.
Checker
Cberp
Origma5 Men
you gibe bin' LA PALINAS
T
ap'5
Seward Market
lalt PALI
CIG AR
LEE and CADY --- Detroit, Michigan
STARTING — LIGHTING — IGNITIO
Genuine Parts — Factory Service
AUTO ELECTRIC & SERVICE CORP