41. PAGE FOUR 7fl t • Nt___ (ititoruc.7. re/ - LIE 3 EMIT EWISII eIRMI Pubii.hili mons.. •• ■ •••• ■■ • • ■ • ••••••••• ■ • • Weakly by Th. Jewish Chronicle PublishIng Co, Ins . Joseph J. Cummins, President and Editor Jacob H. Schakne, General Manager totem! as Second-elm. muter Match 3, 1.16, s the I'0 , tolloe at Detroit. Mich.. under the Act of March It, 1.114 General Offices and Publication Building 850 High Street West Telephone: Glendale 9300 • Cable Address. Chronicle London Oltoe 14 Stratford Place, London, W. 1, England Subscription, in Advance $3.00 Per To fissure publication, all correspondence and news waiter roust reach office by Tuwidayeveninc of each wed.. Year this Detrolt Citsonicle Invitee eorre , torndeLee on 1.1111JYCI ■ of inter. t to the Jewish people, but disclaim.respen•lbIlity for an iodur•etnent of tbe views expreseed by the writers. December 5, 1924 Kislev 8, 5685 British and American Elections. In Great Britain 1 I JCWS were returned to Parlia- ment and in the United States eight Jews were return- ed to Congress. \\'e arc not at all flattered by the re- turns, since we have eight times as many Jews as Great Britain. Another significant feature of the election, especially in Britain, was the fact that Jewish candi- dates were defeated in preponderatingly Jewish dis- tricts. The Britisher votes on issues, policies, princi- ples and not for men who belong to a certain faith or have a certain creed. This, however, is not the whole story. The Jews in Britain have become integrated, though not assimilated. They are Britishers whose Jewishness is not thereby thinned or rubbed out. \Ve do hear occasionally of Hilaire Belloc, of Gilbert Chesterton, or the Morning Post and sonic other anti- Semitic propagandists, but in the whole election cam- paign we did not hear of any special appeals made on behalf of bigotry, intolerance or anti-Semitism. Eng- land has not an organization like our Ku Klux Klan. Although it would not be in strict truth to say that they are entirely free from anti-Semitism, that Nordic Protestant country is too sound to Make an important issue of such humbuggery and clownishness as the Klan. Imagine how odd and quixotic it would strike us if we read of Sussex or Kent or ally other division of England being Klan or anti-Klan. Fancy opposition to Sir Alfred Mond by the Kleagles and Dragons of Lon- don on the ground that he is a Jew. The whole business does seem preposterous and yet the Britisher of today is of the same stock, has the same traditions, language and background as our meddlesome, benighted Dragon or Kleagle. The two great Anglo-Saxon peoples show great cultural differences. • Is it not possible that the constant blatant cry of superiority of our American Nordic is based upon a sub-conscious feeling of inferiority? Is it not possible that all these activities and manifestations which insist upon adherence and conformity with the Nordic ideal arc evidences of a sub-conscious feeling of ineptness and weakness? \Ve offer these suggestions not as a complete ex- planation, but we are persuaded that a group as ignor- ant and illiterate as the Klan must have some misgiv- ings as to its worthiness. To return to the elections ill the sister countries of Anglo-Saxon cultures. The fact that 1.1 Jew's were elected is not as meaningful as the fact that -I I were candidates. We have not the figures for the United States, but we dare say that not more than 15 were candidates. This indicates that the Jew was not acceptable to the leaders any more than to the electorate in this country, while just the opposite con- dition obtained in Britain. Although we place much blame upon the spirit which has been fomented in Am- erica against alien groups, we are not unmindful of the fact that the Ghetto still clings tenaciously to the Jew in America. our people will gradually lose their Ghet- to ghosts. The inter-racial, inter-group animosities will gradually, though slowly, disappear among the ele- ments which go to make America and men will be chos- en for fitness, worth and as representing issues, policies and principles of social and economic impOrt. we are not As the matter stands in the year 1921 especially pleased with the election of eight Jewish Congressmen, for that is no achievement when com- pared with the 11 members of Parliament returned by our Anglo-Saxon neighbors across the sea. Even though we are not jubilant, we are not hope- less, for we have the firm conviction that out of all the searching shall come a finer, a sounder, understanding of our own shortcomings and weaknesses. once they are properly evaluated and after they sink deep into our consciousness we shall be able to correct these dis- proportions and maladjustments. Religious Unity. The Church of England. Unitarians, Quakers. Congregationalists. Presbyterians. \Vesleyans and Jews were represented at a conference held recently in Lon- don. The conference was held for the purpose of achieving unity among, the religious groups in Great Britain. Even though their aims may not be attained and their purposes achieved, such gatherings hold forth a promise of understanding which cannot but have a salutary influence upon British life. Nothing has been more prolific as a hate producer than lack of knowledge of the other man's beliefs and point of view. The mere fact that one is ready to listen to the other man's position indicates It broad tolerance which makes possible the removal of prejudice and bit- terness. \Ve are not informed as to the outcome of the con- versations and discussions. but from this distance we feel certain that. although agreements were reached in certain vital matters, in fundamentals a complete rap- prochement is quite unlikely, that is, unless the view of some of the denominations mentioned have changed very radically. If all the representatives were Modern- ists, or had subscribed substantially to the Unitarian creed, then indeed wou'd a unity conference be preg- nant with possibilities of excellent results. But the Church of England and the Presbyterian Church. al- though not Fundamentalist to the core as are the Fund- amentalists of America, according to the Reverend Harry Emerson Fosdick, have not all embraced the Modernist position. As Jews we certainly can have no serious quarrel with these Modernists and Unitarians who hold Jesus of Nazareth in great reverence and who accept the monotheistic view of Judaism. The life of Jesus, freed of the fable and the miraculous. is a life of great beauty iSgra"?eZt.sZ274err,:t.5 - r 4v and heroism and Jews will at all times reverence the heroic and praise the beautiful. As Jews we could never accept the myths and miracles in the life of Jesus and his claim of divine origin and immaculate conception was beyond Jewish credulity. Today the :Modernists and Unitarians take a decidedly Jewish position. which makes it possible for us to join hands tvith them in any movement which will bring good-will. tolerance and happiness to humanity. :Modernists have only confirmed the position %Odell Judaism has maintained for 1900 years, and this is not said in the spirit of arrogance or with it view of show- ing cur : upreine knowledge. The London conference is at straw in the wind which bodes well for the religious unity of the western world. Such a unity will be a real achievement of the peoples of western etvilization. Indeed, it will exert au influ- ence upon many of the social and economic problems which are sorely trying this same people. A Most Wonderful People. During the hysterical period of the war some of us learned to appreciate the genius of the German people. It was not the intention of the propaganda agencies to create such an impression, but who could escape the conviction that a people Who were capable of amazing exploits and well-nigh impossible accomplishments were other than extraordinary. The ramifications of their influence and activity extended to the remotest parts of the world. They wielded a magical, uncanny power where it was least expected. This supernal na- tion had its day in the sun, its glory was evanescent, and now it is once more iust an ordinary, respectable member of the family of nations. Certain German- ophiles must regret the transient splendor, for it is an ineffable joy to know that one is omnipotent and omnis- cient. This great distinction, however. has been con- ferred upon Israel, not for a season, but for generations. If we would be modest, DUE active enemy propagandists load us with such powers and capacities that, despite ourselves, wemust recognize our own inexplicable genius. Heretofore we had been informed by competent and reliable authorities that we controlled the destinies of Russia, that our fateful influence determinedthe policy of Germany, Austria. Hungary, Poland and that in Rou- mania the unseen hand of Israel played a not unim- portant role. ' We have been flattered and edified by these panegyrics, for what insignificant minority has ever done such miraculous things or exercised such an influence, whether it be for good or ill? But the peak of our greatness has been revealed to us in a book by one Nesta Webster entitled "The Real Jewish Peril." Now aye know why the Conservative government fell in Britain some nine months ago. Read her precious tvisdoni: 'the causes of the recent debacle of the Conservative government are still obscure; but the fact remains that it was precisely at a moment when the Conservative organiz- ation had passed largely into Jewish hands that Conserva- tism met with the most astounding disaster in the whole of its history. Now. there you have the whole story. The secret is out. \\Ito could fail to be convinced upon such in- disputable testimony of such a creditable and well in- formed witness as Nesta Webster? What Jews got control of the Conservative organization? Such a trif- ling matter is of no consequence. And we must con- clude that, since the Conservative government is again in power with a clear majority of 2(11), it has passed out of Jewish hands and into the hands of Hilaire Belloc, the Morning Post and the intimates of Nesta Webster. But do not think that our appalling, though sinis- ter. influence ends with the domination of the Conser- vative party. Not so, for The Patriot, commenting up- on the delectable morsel of Nesta Webster. has this to say: The selection of the first Jewish secretary of state for India led quickly to disorders on a scale previously un- known; to a greater loss of life than had occurred in all the previous years since the great mutiny and to a situa- tion now beginning to be realized fraught with a great danger to the Indian people and to the empire. No doubt Mahatma Gandhi and the non-violent. non-co-operation movement in India was precipitated by the appointment of a Jewish secretary for India. It is really a pity that one of these bedlamites cannot con- nect the Japanese earthquake with the appointment of some Jew to it judges h ip. The twaddle of Nesta Webster is printed and pub- lished; these infantile stupidities are seriously com- mented upon. This gossip and slander forms the groundtvork upon which a whole anti-Semitic structure is built. The gullible and feeble-witted ones accept all this as gospel. Nesta Webster, The Patriot and the Dearborn In- dependent must have their daily feast of hatred, even though they make of us the most remarkable minority in the whole history of civilization. Pay your dollar and become h private, pay a hun- dred dollars and become a captain, in the Anti-Satan Federation, it new league of Gentiles organized by none other than the impecunious Czarist General, Count Artemi Ivan Chenys Spiridovick. The general is am- bitious as well as perspicacious, he sees a fortune for himself in a membership of 200.000.000. Yet we can hardly blame hint if he chooses to earn an honest penny by appealing to the gullible rather than do the menial work which has been the lot of a host of his former comrades in arms. It is not surprising that the general is one of the most ardent propagandists for Grand Duke Cyril. self-appointed Czar of All the Russian. The cat is out of the bag. The Klan proposes to in- stitute a nation wide economic boycott against Jews and Catholics. Frankly. this is a welcome bit of news and interesting. if true. No longer is the (inter moti- vated by that high courage of the martyr and crusader. The leaders no longer conceal the real purposes of r•dsoint- hoodlumism. It is really a heavy task to fight the imponderables represented by the shining sword of ideals when protected by the burnished shield of pur- ity. The field of economics with its commodities, prices, values and all those tangibles grasped by every- one simplifies the whole matter. Even a Nordic Protes- tant will hardly gird his loins and buckle the shining armour of 100 per cent Americanism to enrich another Klan member whose wares are inferior and whose prices are extortionate. Beware of the crusader who fights in the cause of hate. , IPA 71, • ..2•01,1% • k ". ••10, yam, ../A -316,•.„14, .rek • 118_.• AS WE GO:, ALONG 1 Survival Or Extinction---Problem Of Jewry By ..,..,maalasolaisimatauttimaaastalij It'epvrioht ELISHA M. FRIEDMAN. 1,21 In J Telegraphic Agene, Beauty. \‘ '11EN analysts of we,-tern Iition point to the "glory that , Greece and the grandeur that reeall,tig the heritage of Is atity and philesophy bequeathed by liellas and the priticiple, of law and government formulated by Roman I tilers. the Jew counters, not neves- sarily in a spirit of defense, by sug- gesting that his people bentowed on the human race a by no means un- lovely gift, the moral law. the funda- ment of orreial jlistirr 111141 the prin- ciple 1.f the fatherhood of God and the brotherhood of man. But while the Greek genius, stately as it i s, symbolizes, like the urn on which John Keats lavished an ex- quisite a long stilled fertility and power, the Jewish genius is ac- tive today in a thousand and one realms, despite the livid flames that have been reared about the several habitation- of Israel. And what is more. the Jewish will to express it- self, discerdant as its manifestations !nay neenl, reveals an urge toward beauty which should blossom forth, in the coliner days that will come, into an art of great nobility and literature that will exude the fresh- ness of water springs. Where? In the land whence all that is en- during 81111 significant in the Jewisit capacity was brought into form. Pal- estine, by virtue of its very poverty, its very primitive circumstances. its very newness, has called to itself the adventurous of spirit among the ,Iews of tumble-down Europe and is giving them the materials that may be fash- ioned into distinctive art forms, mu- sic of unmistakable motifs, litera- ture that will quicken the soul and social and spiritual torinulae that will 1 . 0111e nearer to satisfy the hunger, crudely and often malignantly ex- pressed, of the werld's peoples for simplicity, for righteousness, for peaceful conditions, for realization in the larger sense. We sat inthe living room of a suc- cessful man of affairs. an art lover. There were many things he could show us which would testify to his cultural interests. But the thing which he seemed to prize with a truly vivid pleasure teas a book which had just tionte into his possession. an il- lustrated interpretation of King Solo- mon's "'flu' Song o f Songs," done in unforgettable color and design by an artist the scene of whew labors is the Ilezilli.1 School of Arts and Crafts in .lent Mem. The artist? You may never have heard his name. But what passion and integrity that book of hand-wrought text and brilliant, subtle. eager and withal sombre interplay of color and design contained within its stately covers. The creative spirit was as manifest in that book as it is in the rhythmic swing and clang of the picks and shovels of the pioneers or in the song of the children who :try utter- ing forth a new folk leer and new melodic forms. Intelligenaic us have supreme faith in our- 1 • selves. Let us look upon our- selves as though we really were what \ye should like our neighbors to re- gard us. For example, it is supreme- ly satisfying to be known as a cul- tured man or woman. IM not people like to bask in the light of him who pos•sses what is good in literature and the essential in history, who ap- preciates music intelligently, who has a working acquaintance with the fun- damentals in science, who can dif- ferentiate a work of art of the Re- naissance period from a painting of Monet or Whistler? But, you will ask. what shall they do who cannot display the aforesaid accomplishments? To these a word of comfort may be sp o ken. The sug- gestion for the cheering word was re- ceived an we read an item in a Yiai. dish paper recently. A lecturer of distinction had come to town. A series ,,f lectures were arranged for hint and an appeal to the "intelligenzia" of the city- was broad- rant. Thus was the appeal wonted: "You. the intelligent men and women. to whom the wisdom of Professor Thus-and-So should make a strong appeal, should not fail to attend the lectures at the Culture Lovers' Hall arranged by the Society for the Pro- motion of Scientific and Artistic Knowledge." What more facile formula could he devised than the one to which the aforesaid announcement gives rise. Go to the Culture Lovers' Hall meet- ings, ye who would esteem yourself of the intelligenzia, listen to what transpires and be wise. ET Unpleasant. /ONLY a few yeah ago Jacob Schiff V-T was a bulwark "(Jewish spiritual strength in the United States, Here was a man who never tired of giving f his wealth to further Jewish learn- ing. Ile is dead but a few years and yet his children by their presence seemed eager to honer the sen of a wealthy man who was born a Jew and who identified himself with one of the Protestant faiths. And this non, hav- ing been reared as a Protestant, now appears ready to embrace Catholicism for the sake of the girl whom he re- cently married. We have 110 quarrel with any man in the matter of religion. That is a man's perminal affair. But how can we regard with equanimity the grow- ing flirtation with Christianity of ',overfill Jewish figures who, either through family tradition or geiduine conviction, ((.copy posithms of direct- ing power in institutions of Jewish learning such as the Jewish Theologi- cal Seminary and Ilehrew Union Col- lege. The situation is by no means pleasant to contemplate. r oas t I .1.r • P. •• •.• rtiele is 0171. hook 'Surskel Or a,,ther nteI n 1.,Istion of 1.. • • •• • ■ 1 lhallT III iev h race, adaptive, re- 'II.,- sour,', fel aid creative. has a positive contribution to make at any stage of evolving mankind, scientific its well as ethical. The possibilities of the future are filled with hope. When Poland shall have freed her four million, Ukrtiine and Roumania their four million, when America's hungry-minded Jews sihall have solved their economic dif- ficulties- Chattel] said, "It takes three generations to produce a re- search worker" -the question of th e cultural value of the Jewish race w'll no longer need to be asked. The sad aspect of this situation i the thorough estrangement of the upper stratum of this people. which U1/011 reaching the intellectaal and social level of its environment is skimmed off, leaving a culturally de- pleted nmss. TIT average of intel- ligence found in each of the four re- ligious classes as grouped by RunMn bears this out. Except in Frankfoet and a few other Places where Ortho. dozy is based nn fainiiy tradition, the first class, loaa 51 in culture. is un- influenced by the conflict between a static religion and a dynamic environ- ment, whereas the fourth class, high- est in western culture, is assimilated. The preceding exposit inn points to the cottelusitin that the imrmat and effective functioning of the Jewish people. as indeed, if any People, is conditioned by a free and untratm nieled national life, since, failing that condition, the energies of the race will be expended in the mere effort nf self-nreservation. Under diaspor- ic conditions, the energies of the race will he expended in the mere effort of self-preservation. Under diasonric conditions. however. it is clear that the task of preserving the undoubted- ly valuable race-potentialities of the people and of securing the conditions fur their healthy expression devolves upon the cultured Jew. The assump- tion of that task necessitates the ac- live identifiention on the part of the cultured Jew with his pimp le as It whole, a condition which is becom- ing increasingly infrequent. And here one is confronted by the initial question: How shall Jews bring into adjustment mndern toilture and the conditions of modern Jewish life? Or is it that Jewish life is exhausted, does it stand Powerless before the gritat crisis? Can Jews be men of science and of affairs. or mu-I such relin- quish their religion? A cosmeg.ny, utterly at variance with the Biblical deserintion, a nal- iteentoloby that contradicts the Gen- e account, a world of immutable law in which the miracles are not the violations, but the regular mani- festations of infinitesimal and infin- ite forces, an anthropology which shows the taboo of certain foods 14111011/2 most early tribes, a compara- tive religion which shows ethical codes similar to and antedating the Sinaitic revelation—will Judaism re- juvenate itself in the face of these attacks as Rabbinism has done under other conditions? As if by the hand of some master scientist, a test portion of Israel has been isolated to attempt this problem. Let us take observations and films' conclusions so that the hulk of Is- rael tnay profit by the experiment. Geiger, Holdheim, Frankel, Fried- lander and Jacobson and their assn. vial!, attempted, in rabbinical synods. to solve the problems of maladjust- ment of Jewish and Occidental cul- tures several generations age in Ger- many. At first there was merely a formal adjustment; the phil,,,phy of the movement followed the feet, as in all history. The doctrine of the Reform move- ment divorced Palestine from Jewish life in the diaspora, discarded the personal Messiah, substituting the Messianic destiny of Israel; the sac- rifices, the priesthood and its me- morial symbols were abandoned. Ac- cording to the new version. Israel was not in exile; therefore, it never hoped to return. The destruction was a blessing, so that Israel by its disper- sion, might spread its !Mission to the non-Jews. However, the ceremonies were a riddle. Denying, as Reform rahhi , did, the element of Jewish itatietolinm. how could they still ad- here to the national factors----eircum- etsion. the dietary laws ,,, bath that were no vital m the people and its pint' Honed Jewish ceremon,. files. A dichotomy int., , ceremonial law, or iota r, national law, with the .,'• feren s that only the f,,,,, • • be adhered to, loft the I.r ceremonial law either um ' to be dropped, neither de i natives. The dogma of Bete,. ism is as enthraring- as the • nowt —the fatherhood of a brotherhood of man, the ele, • the Messianic destiny uf Obligation of right livo, nitinn of the devehtmect , i law. et To the undoubted credit ,f I: he it said that it recognize,! .1, damental principle of all life t growth and decay. Unfortur,e. failed to recognize the true er of evolation- that the Nom, grow out of the past. It' ni- the historic language, by di-i o , the Jewish hope for the re-t,-r,' of Palestine, by the aboliti m ... , , fain ceremonies, Reform Judhi- itself off from the post. The r.' ens refused to be the heirs , fathers. Rya reduction of the lion of their children, they themselves the last of the I and after them—extinction. V, ti Judged by its effects, Ref,ir.. ism has failed. An asst's the fact that in the abolitie , brew, the great source book- ,o ish life have been sealed, it:- now and anon by some teas. into various vernaculars of p Jewry. In the scant educatiee thc children. the habit of .b.e,•It thinking has been allowed to die. By the excision of the ceremonies. the centripetal forces holding the Jew,: together were rendered inoperat Ir e and the centrifugal forces of the 1.n. vironment scattered them to ,gsoni. lation. The abandoning of the fer- vent hope of Israel to live again, to live freely, to express itself and m. 3 restored people to he a light t, the nations as of old, has left Reform cold, hopeless and drifting. Thehope for a restoration to Tri- estine is, has Item!, and will be the vital force in Jewish life. With it- decay go the people. the .Imes, h11,1 its creature, the religion, Judai-,11. Today, repressed as it is, its life furies express themselves alike in the Yom Kippur appeal of the old (helm_ dox rabbi to young men "not to , 1,•-rt the banner of your people" as in the need for the frequent denial- by some anti-Zionist rabbis that the .lee- ish people lives or that its lanmia.• merits revival. Only in their historic land where the Jews will be in the majarity, where they can, without fear of 1,,.. cullarity, assert their culture. is a Jewish mode of life possible. Deny this and the life in dispersiett be- comes an aimless prospect which only the sentimentalist can entPrta', To preserve the Jewish its leaders are seeking to n-star, t , Jewish education in the Galuth the predominant position accorded b, it from earliest times and conethl,,I non-Jewish educators to be a 1 factor in its historic survival education of children to strong religious and histore,' seriousness, the parallel denude , . of prophetic Hebrew, all the Galuth life support and , a sense of the historic contimii - geographic unity of Israel. Whether in pew or in pulp , ' difficulty confronting Jewry . extensive ignorance of Jewish 11 -,f the development of its cults , of the significance of a living.. • ing institutionalism for preseni , Jewish people intact. The unhi-,.. Orthodox, that untraditim, ditionalist, magnifies one stage ,.• past at the expense of the pr , The radical reformer exalts Oh to the disparagement of all III , ' To preserve the Jew in ti outside of Palestine, the eel, revalued, are now receiving a - ranee that history and legalism a- N , .. rt to them in the past. ,alvation of a single sinner' , but the preservation of Israel' - not individual salvation by et- ance but group life by expr, this has become the motive far ishing traditions. The pre-u rt , unbroken of the line of this old people and the globe-wide of Israel, this has become the d'etre of the new legalism, whi, actuating the historical school in • .lewish community. 011,t1 "M111411P19111111111igl'..,,t1114111!IVIT:11.111rIr'11111111.1 1111i11111111.111 4111411'1111MER111111111',1111111911111111111 , 1111111q111111111114111j11111l',1111111111111111111111idi Ask Of Me • "Ask of Me, beautiful mouth, What (lost thou ask of Me? For thy suppliant cry !lath ascended on high Inclining My ear to thy plea." "First with the lion we met, Next came the leopard's leap, We were fain to take flight From our garden's delight And into a hiding place creep. "Hardly these creatures had passed, Sated with Judah's spoil, Than the wild ass we feared Out of midnight appeared To trample and dwell on our soil, Inquiry. ERE is a suggestion for a thesis for an enterprising young scholar desiring to win a doctorate. Let him make a study of the outcome of the promises to investigate, inquire into, probe and search to the bottom of. the pogroms, discriminations, out- breaks, terrorisms and other annoy- ances to which Polish, Russian, Rou- manian, Hungarian and German Jews are subjected from time to time. The findings would be interesting. H It,. • re. INA "Ishmael's offspring command flack to his Arab land, As his mother of old To her mistress was told To return and submit to her hand." SOLOMON INN GAMBOL. (Translated by Israel Zangwill-1 Y. • - W . AIN -3% e‘ •••.0